Here are two articles written by the same author attempting to answer the questions: Will iPads replace backpacks? and Will the iPad replace the simplicity and convenience of paper products for higher-level learning tasks?
I like how Ledesma addresses both questions and highlights numerous advantages in using an iPad. For example:
- An iPad is great tool for research on the Internet and other consumption of web-based media.
- Most desktop computing can be completed using an iPad.
- It is possible to access and/or synchronize your files through the iPad.
- Real-time communication (chat, email, voice) is possible with the iPad.
However, he does acknowledge that there are limitations in screen size and in the ability to access multiple sources easily when using the iPad for certain work.
“Unfortunately, higher-level work, which requires deeper analysis and simultaneous access between multiple sources, may be more than what a single device and small screen can handle.” (2010)
“Technology should make the learning process easier, not harder or more complicated.” (2011)
So, it may seem that students will continue to use their backpacks as they carry around their books, pens and paper which will still be needed for the more academic, higher-order learning tasks.
“Enjoy the iPads for what they are best at, and let’s stop trying to force them to replace tools that they shouldn’t.” (2011)
Ledesma, P. (2011, Nov. 14). iPads in schools: Replacing backpacks? Accessed through Education Week Teacher, Nov. 15, 2011.